This is just my two pennyworth.
I confess, I dont know what the attraction of rear discs on a road-going sd1 is, or how important it it is to have them on a track car, for instance.
However I can more or less see the attraction (with reservations) of fitting uprated front calipers such as the jag system to enhance the stopping power.
As there is a considerable transfer of weight onto the front wheels when braking, the SD1 balance valve directs most of the braking energy to the front wheels. The back brakes being less efficient also get less braking energy. But that balance valve would be rated to account for the difference.
This is important because if the front brakes lock up then it would be a distinct advanvantage for the rear brakes to maintain traction (and drive) to steady the car under braking.
It does not help control of the car if the rear brakes lock up too.
If an even stronger system is fitted to the front brakes then it stands to reason that even more weight is transferred to the front wheels under braking and the back end becomes even lighter.
That would imply that the balance of braking energy would need to be adjustable. Which on a standard setup, it is not.
Worse, if very efficient rear discs are fitted at the same time as an uprated front end then it seems to me that the back brakes are going to lock up much earlier, perhaps even before the fronts.
Correct me if i'm wrong, but that implies braking instability that has disaster written all over it, even for normal braking when not in a straight line.
If such a thing happens in an emergency then I think the car may become uncontrollable, with all the consequences that would imply, such as LIABILITY and INSURANCE issues.
Bearing in mind that SD1 brakes are quite sensitive to poor maintenance and therefor, such a condition may persuade an owner that he needs uprated braking system rather than ensuring that the existing system is operating at peak efficiency
For a regular road-going vehicle in our modern motoring environment I am doubtful of the benefits of creating an unbalanced braking system.
Moreover if the motive for adding rear discs is purely cosmetic, then it also figures that attending to the real issue might take second place.
For my sins I wrote the following analysis of the SD1 braking system which attempts to address all the maintenance issues and also bears close scrutiny before anyone gets hurt.
Only registered users can see links on this forum! Register or Login on forum! |